5 Most Bizarre Missing Person Cases – Top5s
Mysteries & Conspiracies

5 Most Bizarre Missing Person Cases

09 May 2018

Missing person cases where people vanish without a trace are incredibly interesting and yet almost unbelievable at the same time. It seems it is hard for us as humans to accept that someone could disappear as if into thin air, never to be found again.

Not only are missing person cases enigmatic as it is, here are some of the most bizarre cases where the disappearance is actually only the start of a very strange story.

5 Brooke Henson- Missing Since 1999

Brooke Henson- Missing Since 1999

Brooke Henson, a twenty-year-old girl who lived in Southern California, who was at a party with some friends on July 3rd, 1999. After a disagreement with her boyfriend Shane, Brooke left a note to him at around 2 am and walked to the local convenience store which was only a few streets away. Brooke was last seen walking along the road to the convenience store that morning and has never been heard from or seen since.

But in 2006, there was suddenly a huge breakthrough on this missing person case. Someone with the name Brooke Henson had applied for a job as a nanny in New York, and after the employer did an internet search of her name, contacted the authorities after realising Brooke had been a missing person for over six years.

But this was not the good news her family had been hoping for, the real identity of the person claiming to be ‘Brooke Henson’ was instead a girl named Esther Reed, also a missing person who dropped out of high school and disappeared from her hometown after her mother’s death in 1999. In February 2008, Esther was arrested and sentenced to four years in prison, but the whereabouts of the real Brooke is still unknown, and no more information on the case has ever been found.

4 Maura Murray – Missing Since 2004

Maura Murray - Missing Since 2004

After crashing her car on Route 112 in New Hampshire, USA, Maura Murray, a nursing student aged just twenty-one was never seen again. There are many strange elements leading up to this missing person case. On the day of her car crash, Maura had told her professors at university that she was taking a week off from school due to a death in her family, but in fact, this was a lie.

After her crash, a school bus driver who was driving home noticed her on the side of the road. According to some reports, Maura pleaded with the man not to call the police, stating she had already called the AAA, so the man left the scene. Once he was home, he called the police, but Maura was nowhere to be found and has never been seen since.

Despite some evidence suggesting that Maura had perhaps wanted to disappear on purpose, her family still believe she had been abducted and are still searching for her today. Interestingly enough, there has been new information about Maura’s case despite it being over a decade old. A youtube user by the name of “Mr112dirtbag” posted videos claiming he had information surrounding Maura’s disappearance.

On the 8th anniversary of Maura’s disappearance, the man posted a youtube video of him laughing with the words, “Happy Anniversary” flashing at the end.

3 Benjaman Kyle – Missing Since ?

Benjaman Kyle - Missing Since ?

Benjaman Kyle is indeed a bizarre missing person case, because, in this case, it’s Benjamin’s past that is missing, rather than the person himself.

On August 31st, 2004, Kyle was found naked and burnt by a Burger King in Richmond Hill, Georgia. A Burger King employee had found him and called the police, the beaten and unconscious Kyle was then rushed to hospital. Once he had woken up, it was discovered that he had no memory of who he was, and without any form of identification, the name Benjaman Kyle was formed out of the initials of Burger King.

Kyle had three deep depressions in his skull which people attribute to his amnesia and memory loss, and over a decade later, Kyle still has no memory of his past life or who he had been.

Despite all of the publicity his case has generated in the past, unbelievably no one has ever come forward to say that they know him or are related to him. Due to the unusual circumstances of this case, there are many theories about who Kyle is and his past, some say he is even faking it!

2 Nicholas Barclay – Missing Since 1994

Nicholas Barclay - Missing Since 1994

Nicholas Barclay was a thirteen-year-old boy who after playing basketball with his friends in his home town of Texas, was never seen again. That was until 1997 when a boy in France claiming to be him was flown to the United States and ‘reunited’ with the family. Although the boy had different coloured eyes to Nicholas and spoke with a French accent, the family believed that this was indeed their son, who had been sold to a prostitution ring and sent to live in France.

The boy lived with the family until 1998 when a local private investigator became suspicious of the differences in appearances between Nicholas and the boy claiming to be him. In February 1998 the FBI gained permission to take his DNA, and it was found that the boy was not Nicholas but in fact a French impostor named Frederic Bourdin.

Bourdin was sentenced to six years imprisonment and even admitted himself he could not believe the family believed he was their son for as long as they did.

Some people believe that Nicholas’ family are responsible for hiding the whereabouts or perhaps even the murder of their son, and therefore jumped at the chance to have Frederic cover it up. A documentary about the case, The Imposter, sheds some more light on this strange case and asks more question about the family’s willingness to accept this boy as their missing son.

1 Walter Collins – Missing Since 1928

Walter Collins - Missing Since 1928

A somewhat similar case to the Nicholas Barclay disappearance, Walter Collins was a nine-year-old boy who went missing while his mother was at work. When she returned home, Walter was nowhere to be found. She called the police but was told he needed to have been missing for twenty-four hours before they could search, so she took on the search herself, frantically searching the streets for him.

After the police department had faced negative publicity for failing to solve the case, a boy claiming to be Walter was found, and a public reunion was organised by police who wanted to gain positive popularity to counteract the bad publicity they had received. But on seeing the boy, Walter’s mother Christine claimed the boy was not her son.

Despite dental records proving that the boy was not her son, Captain Jones of the police department had Christine committed to a mental hospital where during this time the boy eventually admitted that he was not Walter but in fact a boy named Arthur Hutchins Jr.

After Christine had been released from the mental hospital, a ranch owner named Gordon Stewart Northcott was arrested for a series of abductions and murders of young boys in the area. Although evidence points to this man as possibly being the abductor and murderer of Walter, he had denied ever meeting Walter and the fact he could not describe Walters appearance gave Christine hope that her son was still alive.

The film Changeling with Angelina Jolie was based partly on this case and is a great insight into the events that took place and how traumatising they must have been for Christine to not only lose her child but also be told that another boy was him and declared publicly crazy in the media.


5 Terrifying Trick Or Treats Gone Wrong

Anchored in mischief and mayhem, All Hallows Eve, is a time for ghoulish costumes, scary...

Something Really Weird Is Going On Here!! Can Anyone Help?

This is a 100% true story that I need to get out there because I...

Paranoid

Growing up I was put in mental hospitals because I’ve been very aggressive and I...

5 Most Insane Lab Created Hybrids & Animals

Laboratories are the hub of life changing medicines and treatments, from cancer research to brain...

5 People Who Risked It All For The Perfect Selfie

Probably less than ten years ago if someone told you that you could die taking...

Look Closely….What Can You See?

Kampen Glass Factory Ghost A few years ago me and my best friend Lennart were...

5 Things That Will Happen To Earth In The Next 100 Years

Planet Earth is constantly changing. Whether we notice it or not, both small and massive...

5 World Famous Mysteries And Conspiracies That Have Possibly Been Debunked!

To the mysterious photos supposedly showing the long-lost Amelia Earhart, to one of the most...

5 Seemingly Creepy Things Spotted On Google Maps

The world is a vast and beautiful place, and most people are not fortunate enough...

5 Devoted Pet Owners Whose Beloved Animals Attacked

To many of us, our pets are as important to us as members of our...

5 Fascinating Facts About Giants

The common perception of a mythical Giant today is a supersized human, often with a...

My Great Grandma’s Grave Ghost

Hi, my name is Karolina, I’ve been watching your videos for almost 3 years now...

Anyone Know What This Is All About???!! (ns 049 flying crow)

01111001 01101111 01110101 00100000 01100001 01110010 01100101 00100000 01100110 01100001 01110010 00100000 01100110 01101111 01101100...

5 Reasons Eating Crickets Isn’t As Disgusting As It Sounds

Entomophagy is the term used for humans who eat insects as a food source, in...

Dark Premonitions

When I was around 13 (I’m 19 now) , I was told a story by...

5 Rogue Animals Who Turned Serial Killer

There are numerous cases of humans attacked by animals, but fewer are those where the...

5 Facts About The Day America Was Invaded By Martians

It has gone down as one of the most notorious broadcasts in history and in...

5 Interesting Facts About The Moon

When I admire the wonders of the sunset or the beauty of the moon, my...

The Day The Sky Turned Green?

I’m sharing this because I want to know if anyone has ever had a similar...

Malaysia Airlines Flight 370 Mystery Latest: Aviation Experts Suggest Crash Was Deliberate…

The disappearance of Malaysian Airways flight MH370 is one of the biggest modern day aviation...

5 Most Bizarre Missing Person Cases

Missing person cases where people vanish without a trace are incredibly interesting and yet almost...

5 Unsolved Black Hole Mysteries

Have you ever wondered what would happen to you if you were caught inside a...

5 Interesting Facts About Alan Turing’s Life | The Man Who Broke The Enigma Code

Developed by a German engineer at the end of World War I, the Enigma Machine...

The Genius That Was Stephen Hawking

On March 14th, 1879 one of the greatest theoretical physicist of all time was born,...

5 Real Life Killer Clowns That Are Even Scarier Than Pennywise…

With the release of 2017’s ‘IT’ one of horror movies most terrifying characters has been...

The Worlds Most Dangerous Game? | The Elevator Ritual: Step by Step Guide, Rules & Tips

The Elevator Ritual Game is thought to have originated from a Korean Website, although this...

5 Incredible Superpowers You Probably Didn’t Know Your Pet Has

Ask anyone who owns a pet, and they’ll give you a reason why their pet...

5 Most Poisonous Frogs on the Planet!

Some of the most stunning plants and animals on the planet are often the most...

5 Time Travel Conspiracies

Time travel has always been a fascinating topic and has led to the birth of...

5 Remarkable Cases Where Bodies Have Been Frozen In Time

When someone dies, the body will immediately start to decompose starting with the internal organs…....

Incredibly Creepy Experiences At Wissahickon House, Germantown, Philadelphia

Dear Top5s I want to start off by saying I’m an avid fan of your...

The Mysterious Case Of Kayelyn Louder | 5 Things That Don’t Add Up

Compassionate, kind and considerate; these are just some of the words used by family and...

5 UFO Incidents The World Forgot

Take a look at the list below, remarkably each of these events actually happened. They...

5 Horrifying Facts About Auschwitz Concentration Camp

Probably the most infamous of all the Nazi concentration camps, the name Auschwitz conjures up...

5 Theories On What Lies Beyond The Observable Universe

Have you ever thought about how big the universe is? Thanks to our continuously updated...

5 Creepy Places With Horrific Back Stories

We all are aware of that one house in the neighbourhood…. The one that is...

5 Amazing Facts About Albert Einstein & His Life

Albert Einstein is widely credited as one of the smartest and most influential men of...

Strange Happenings In Haunted House In England

I used to live on a little island at the bottom of England, near the...

New Mexico Witch

I am not absolutely sure of the date as it was some time ago and...

Will I live…or die? A True Paranormal Encounter

Alright, so this encounter I’m about to tell everyone about is one of my scary...

5 Famous People Who Went Missing, Then Turned Up Safe…

Every day hundreds of people disappear, either by choice or otherwise. Only a very small...

5 Ways To Spot A Psychic Scam Online…

Finding a decent astrologer can be tough. You can ask friends and family for recommendations,...

5 Animal Heroes Of The First And Second World War

When we remember the two World Wars, we probably give little thought to the animals...

Please Help Me Explain This Creepy Photo!

I’m going to stay persistant with this picture because I need an explanation. I took...

5 Notorious Medieval and Renaissance Witches

As we grew up, adults told us stories about the good and evil creatures that...

I Saw The Same Ghost That Photobombed Family Snap At Roundhay Park

It must have been back in 2010, my four friends and me were in our...

Recurring Old Hag Dream and Sleep Paralysis?

My story may seem very farfetched to anyone who doesn’t believe in supernatural events, but...

Ghost Hunting Essentials | 5 Pieces of Equipment For Every Aspiring Ghost Hunter

For centuries, we as the human race have held an electric fascination with spirits, the...

My Young Daughter Was Taken Over By A Frightening Stickman

I don’t want to leave my name, but this is the story of my families...

5 Most Haunted Places & Unexplained Events in Webster Groves, Missouri…

Webster Groves is a quiet suburb of St. Louis, in the heart of the United...

Creepy Nights At The Museum Of Welsh Life in Cardiff

My original plan in life towards the end of my teens was to go to...

5 Tragic Incidents That Took Place on Friday the 13th….Coincidence or Curse?

Friday the 13th is a day that many people believe to be unlucky or even...

5 Clever Hoaxes That Fooled The World

Most people like to think that they would be able to spot when something wasn’t...

5 Possible Explanations For The Amityville House Hauntings

5 Amityville House: Haunted or Not?When you look at the house on 108 Ocean Avenue...

5 Mythical Creatures & Cryptids That Could Actually Be Real

Throughout time we have always told tales of fantastic creatures lurking in the distant corners...

5 Famous Actors You Never Knew Were World War II Heroes!

World War II affected the lives of so many, as young men all over the...

Knock Knock, Who’s There? – A Story Shared by Top5s Top Woman

I’ve never really gone looking for anything supernatural and was a very innocent child growing...

5 Interesting Facts About Diana, Princess Of Wales

Born Diana Spencer in July 1961, she went on to become one of the most...

The UFO Death Conspiracy | 5 Mysterious Deaths Linked to Unidentified Flying Objects

In 1971 internationally renowned comic book writer and keen amateur UFO Researcher Otto Binder published...

5 Facts About The Terrifying Case of The Southend Werewolf

For the fanatics of the era that was populated by teen vampire characters and assorted...

5 Terrifying Haunted Hospitals And Insane Asylums

Hospitals are a frightening place to visit just by their nature, the sterile corridors and...

The 5 Facts Behind The Real “Conjuring” Movie Family | The Perron Family

When you hear the name Perron, most people don't give it a second thought. But...

5 Interesting Facts About The Life of The Worlds Most Notorious Pirate | Captain Blackbeard

Have you ever wondered how a pirate would want to be remembered? What went through...

A Time Slip, Perhaps?

Hello, my name is Shylah, and the other day I had one of the strangest...

Privacy Preference Center

Close your account?

Your account will be closed and all data will be permanently deleted and cannot be recovered. Are you sure?